“I can fix him” are the most romantic four words in the English language. Naturally, everyone reacts to them with alarm.
People will say that “fixing him” is literally impossible and also will definitely backfire. It’s unfair to him (he never asked!) and unfair to you (he’ll never thank you!). Wanting to fix him means you shouldn’t be together or maybe that you must love him unconditionally or somehow both at once. Even if we can’t agree on why you mustn’t fix him, we all agree that you mustn’t.
And yet: he needs fixing. He can be fixed. People are constantly changing — it can’t all be random drift. If anyone can fix him, surely the person who loves him can.
Or her. The cliché is that women hope to change their husbands while husbands hope their wives never change — both end up disappointed. This may be a result of women hitting the marriage market earlier and dating guys who are slightly underbaked. I’ve certainly been tempted to “fix her”, for various values of her and of fix. In this essay, I’ll mostly stick with fixing him for simplicity. I recommend reading this from both points of view: the fixer and the fixee.
Not Actually Fixing Him
“I can fix him” has two obvious failure modes. The first is: “I’m signing up to live with something I can’t live with”. Abuse, addiction, infidelity, severe disorders. Even if you could fix these eventually, you’ll have to live with them for a long while first. You have to be ready to live with them forever.
If you’re fixin’ to fix someone’s glaring issue, you should have a good answer to why he hasn’t done this already. He’s aware of the problem, aware of its persistence, and aware that he can get you as a partner despite it. You’re starting from a harder difficulty baseline than all the previous attempts to fix it, his and other people’s, and they all failed.
Another thing you shouldn’t be trying to fix is his willingness to commit or escalate the relationship. You can live with it for a while, and that’s the problem: you’re losing time which you can’t afford to lose. And since commitment issues are visible much later than a drug habit, he knows that he can not only get you but also your replacement despite them. If every time you mention moving in he remembers how he’s always dreamt of solo-climbing Kilimanjaro, he’s not the one that can be quick-fixed here.
The other error is when “fix him” means “shape him to my liking”. Throwing out his cargo shorts and making him vacuum the couch aren’t “fixes”. It’s perfectly fine to ask your partner to satisfy your preferences, even if these affect personal choices like summer fashion. Giving more and asking for more are the prerogative of a great couple. But even if you’re tempted to make your dissatisfaction his problem, it’s important not to confuse the two.
These are the failure modes, but success is also possible. It requires wisdom, persistence, charity, and devotion. It’s probably too hard: how many projects in your life have you successfully applied all four of these to? There are easy and productive ways to not fix him instead. Before you attempt any major remodeling, you should at least have some compelling reasons to reject the alternative.
How to Not Fix Him
The first of the four noble truths is dukkha: existence is unsatisfactory. Struggling against this fact leads to suffering — that’s the second of the four. You can always choose equanimity and acceptance.
Life is short. Your partner will die unfixed, and so will you. He has lived thus far with that particular flaw unfixed, and you can as well. Perhaps he doesn’t even see it as a flaw, but simply as a different habit. Are you sure that what you’re trying to fix is the only right way to be, and not simply something you’re used to?
My wife’s family always ate dinner together, and she was upset at my own indifference to shared meals. But Israelis have their big meal at lunchtime when families are apart, and my dad would come home too late for dinner even if we had it. To me there’s nothing special about the dinner table as a setting. When my wife accepted that I’m not purposefully avoiding family time but simply have different eating habits, we could agree on a shared meal schedule without anyone having to be fixed.
You can not fix him for practical reasons. Your partner brings unique strengths that offset your own weaknesses. He has traits that might be too extreme for a single person, but work well as a complement to your own for solving problems together. The flaws you see in him are often the flip side of these strengths.
If you love his charm and how easily he makes friends, he’ll often trip your jealousy sensor when talking to women. If you admire his boldness and risk-taking, he’ll occasionally seem reckless. If you wanted a confident man with strong convictions, you may find him stubborn to a fault.
These flaws mean that he needs you just as much as you need him, to counterbalance his own deficiencies. That’s a good thing, not something to be fixed. A great couple isn’t made of two perfectly-balanced people who could operate solo with no drawbacks. Interdependence is the whole point. If the trait you’re trying to fix is like this, the problem in your relationship might be insufficient separation of responsibilities. Write the postcards yourself if your husband lacks the empathy, and let him deal with challenges that require stoicism.
Finally, a great approach to not fixing your partner is seeing their quirks as their unique artistic expression. If she apologizes too much or if he teases you mercilessly that’s just each person’s commitment to the bit — an aesthetic choice and not a conflict. Every time my wife apologizes for sneezing when she’s alone in the other room, I yell “you better be sorry, or else!” It does nothing to fix her habit in any way, but at least we’re both having fun1.
How to Fix Him
So: something’s wrong with your partner. It’s not bad enough for you to have rejected him upfront, but bad enough that you’re willing to ignore all the warnings about fixing him. You have rejected the path of equanimity, of aesthetic tolerance, and of effective corporate governance. You’re determined to fix him.
The way to fix your partner is the way he’d fix himself: by updating his self-image using psycho-cybernetics. The prerequisites for self-fixing are getting rid of false narratives of failure and setting a clear goal. You both have to agree on these: that the fixing is possible and how exactly being fixed would look like from both of your points of view. You must both be able to imagine the successful end state, the same successful end state.
I called the main phase of the psycho-cybernetic process RLHF:
Your self-image doesn’t change overnight, but it gets updated every minute of your life by observing your actions and their consequences. If you let this process run unchecked, your actions will dig a deep trench of confirmation bias around whatever self-story happened to be there. Orienting your self-image towards success requires two things:
Setting up an environment where you get to act often and succeed sometimes, even if for small stakes.
Updating in the right direction from both success and failure.
People get stuck because they’re disconnected from the actual learning landscape, or because they let failures drag them back instead of pushing them.
The way to fix him is to be his learning landscape. You are the human feedback that provides reinforcement learning. Your boyfriend is a sophisticated neural network. If you knew a better way to fix these than with a huge number of small RL nudges, you’d be negotiating a billion dollar signing bonus with Zuck instead of reading this.
What does RLHF mean? First, that fixing him is going to take a loooong time. Even if your boyfriend generalizes better than GPT, it’s going to take hundreds of input-response pairs. It’s going to take years. If you’re not going to keep your own eyes on the prize for the duration, it’s better not to start.
In RLHF, the only thing that counts is reinforcement of specific behavior. You have to respond when he does something, you have to determine whether he’s made (tiny, incremental) progress or not, and you have to react with genuine gratitude when he has. If you nag him about some behavior when he’s not doing it, he won’t learn anything other than to avoid bringing up the subject. If you respond arbitrarily or only with negative reinforcement, he won’t learn anything besides resentment.
A somewhat funny example is that my wife has done much to improve the quality of my diet, but failed to fix my sleep schedule in any way. The reason is that she’s often there when I decide where and what to eat, but she’s already asleep at midnight when I’m choosing whether to turn in early or play just one more turn of Civ. In the morning, it’s too late for any reinforcement to affect the outcome.
Fixing yourself with RLHF is hard enough. Fixing someone else is, frankly, a crazy undertaking. It’s impossible to follow through if you’re half-hearted about it. It’s not worth it for something minor, or just to feed your own ego. It’s a huge risk: the risk of failure, risk of losing faith halfway, and the bigger risk that fixing him won’t make you happy, satisfied, and grateful. Trying to fix him is a big bet on both of you.
This is what makes “I can fix him” so romantic. Every person on Earth has flaws you simply tolerate or ignore. Some people you have an actual relationship with, and you can ask each other for your preferences. But to embark on fixing someone requires faith, devotion, and commitment for the long term. If you have those, you can fix him.
I’m almost certainly having more fun, but if Terese was having no fun at all she could always stop apologizing.



Just don't try to fix an addict with reinforced learning, you'll run into paradoxical reactions and make everything worse )