Discussion about this post

User's avatar
M J Naylor's avatar

From an evolutionary psychology viewpoint, males from 16 to 25 are designed to be reckless and slightly stupid. In caveman days when a lion approached, the women, children, and older men were all supposed to run away. The young men were supposed to move towards the lion, or pack of lions, to distract it or kill it. That is really stupid on a personal basis. But essential for clan survival.

The reward for the young men was that they demonstrated their ability to provide protection. Individual shows of heroics (particularly if dangerous and stupid) lead to increased standing and therefore mating interest from women. Demand for a high level of emotional intelligence in men wasn’t required, at least until they were older and joined the leadership group.

Younger women, conversely spent a lot of time with older women gathering food and minding children. They needed to negotiate a complex web of personal relationships within that women’s group to achieve their social standing. They were ready to have children and establish a stable mating by late teens (backed by that group of women helpers).

These gender differences are evident in the delay in male frontal lobe development towards the mid 20s, whereas female frontal lobes develop by late teens. We can’t demand that brain development and social hierarchy evolution changes fast just because our modern society wants it. The demand for these changes are very recent. In the 1910’s admired young male behaviour was charging over the top of a trench into intense rifle fire nearly certain to kill you. In the 1940’s young men were applauded for storming beaches despite the dire survival percentages. In the 1950’s men were rewarded for working years in coal pits or factories without complaint despite the dangers and boredom and the early deaths due to workplace pollutants or worn out bodies. Nobody demanded they learn high level emotional relationship skills. (I’m old enough to remember the dads of the 1950s and ‘60s - they weren’t high on the emotional intelligence scale, but they were respected members of the community).

So demanding that young males ‘just develop faster at the emotional relationship skills females require and stop engaging in stupid antics’ is doomed to fail. Young men today are emotionally better and less likely to be emotionally destructive than we ever were in the 1960s. Huge improvement. It’s just that young women have evolved faster and won’t ‘just settle for a stable guy’, like their mothers and grandfathers did.

This is vital as younger people are having fewer relationships and marrying less often and therefore having fewer children.

How do we match the understandable wishes of modern young women with the fact that many young men can’t fulfil those?

Grant's avatar

Why is the burden on women to “start practicing” and “bet on a guy early” instead of on men to grow tf up and learn how to be emotional intelligent?

22 more comments...

Ready for more?