LessOnline is a conference for rationalist-adjacent bloggers whose second iteration was held last weekend. The home page features a selection of notable writers who cover topics like AI, economics, psychology, AI, policy, AI, Effective Altruism, education, life extension, and AI.
You may wonder if the vibe at such a conference would be dry and academic or edgy and stimulating, doomer or optimist, egalitarian or hierarchical. You probably wouldn’t expect the vibe to be free-flowing libidinal energy.
How did a conference with sessions on elastomeric respirators and the Book of Revelation get horny? Like Darwin’s journey on the Beagle, I shall list some field notes from my journey to Lighthaven. Then, perhaps a unifying theory will suggest itself.
1
The venue groundskeeper, Ronny, tweeted about getting a tattoo to commemorate being Aella’s 100th sexual partner. In response, thousands of people all over the internet had an aneurysm. A comment saying “you should have been bullied when you were a kid” from someone who attended Lighthaven last year has 3,400 likes.
Why is everyone so obsessed with a few friends goofing around like any college kids on spring break? Any guy can open Tinder, click on “top picks”, and see women with body counts higher than Aella’s accumulated over men with sillier tattoos than Ronny’s. Hatred this intense usually comes from envy. But it can’t just be envy of having sex with a hot online celebrity. People reacted as if Ronny broke some sacred rule of the universe.
2
Overheard:
People have tried to smear my org with sex abuse for years, and now I’m told to censor what I think about AI labs because someone powerful might be offended? Fuck that shit.
3
My friend “Standard Deviant” gave a talk titled “How I’ve had more sex”. He described the “escalator”: starting a conversation, exchanging compliments, light touch on the arm, etc. The important thing isn’t to rush up the escalator, my friend said, but to move together in synchrony whether you’re taking a step up or a step down.
When women show interest in casual sex, he often asks: do you do this sort of thing often? If they don’t, he often forgoes the opportunity out of an excess of caution.
Afterwards, more women wanted to have sex with him. I joked that women want to have sex not with the tall guy, hot guy, or the famous guy, but with the Schelling point guy. Someone pointed out that tall, hot, and famous are the usual Schelling points.
4
Observing a scrawny, slouching blogger in an ill-fitting jacket give a talk, two women independently declared that he was the sexiest guy at the conference. I observed the man in question for a minute. I noticed that he seemed extremely comfortable addressing a crowd while sitting slouched in an ill-fitting jacket, more comfortable than most people can ever get in front a crowd no matter their dress or status.
5
I have an application to date me up on my old blog, on the view that if a girl enjoys my writing she will certainly enjoy my company as well. A few years ago, I was asked out by a girl who admitted she only read a small bit from one of my posts. She told me:
If you’re a writer, you’re cool. But a lot of people online are creepy and DM you pretending they don’t want to fuck you. The fact that you’ve had this dating form up for years means I can trust you.
6
A group of girls were talking about how it’s obvious that high-status men are sexy and that you can easily tell that by how confident they are. I asked: which is it, the status or the swagger? Is it hot when a guy is high status (e.g., respected as a master in his field) but doesn’t show it, or when he shows high confidence that isn’t really deserved? They scrunched their faces at the thought of either of these, though they couldn’t quite explain why.
7
A woman who writes about casual sex online showed up to LessOnline not being very familiar with the rationalist community. She asked a cuddling couple if they were sex partners and was shocked to hear that they’re just friends. As the evening grew colder, more and more people joined Platonic cuddles on benches around the fire pits. The woman sat apart on a chair, observing with curiosity.
8
Last summer, a story in a major newspaper accused Lightaven of having “racist ties” and hosting conferences with “extreme figures”. This summer saw a 50% increase in LessOnline attendees of all races.
9
Chasing Right Tail
Sex requires trust. Trust requires integrity.
It’s an old idea, though not by any means universal. Fuckbois and pickup artists pursue sex with zero integrity and make fun of “nice guys”. Most people hate that, they try to punish defectors and enforce dating norms that reward being reasonably nice and honest. 99% of the discourse about sex and integrity focuses on the conflict between “sex defectors” and the mainstream.
If we draw the distribution of “integrity and trustworthiness around sex” in the population, we see that these two groups form the left tail and middle hump, respectively. But what about the right tail? What do sexual relations look like when you optimize for trust and honesty far beyond where most people settle?
The right tail is a strange place to be. The struggle for trust flips from trying to convince others to being purely internal. The signals of trust flip to countersignals. Sexual abundance lets people have very high sexual standards, but on very unusual traits.
And everyone who’s never been in a high-trust community is convinced that it’s a sex cult.
Welcome to LessOnline.
The Long Path
You can fool some people all of the time, especially if they want to be fooled. You can fool all the people some of the time, especially if that time is short. You can’t fool an audience of nitpicky autists for a decade.
I didn’t start a rationalist blog 10 years ago with the goal of proving my integrity, and I wouldn’t have stuck with it if that was my goal. It’s the thousands of small choices: accepting a fussy correction, softening a dunk because I could be missing a bit of context, keeping posts up on the site that are really cringe in retrospect. I got so used to readers trying to catch me on any inconsistency1 that I’m surprised no one has called me out yet on the apparent contradiction between this Substack note and this one.2
The goal of LessOnline is to enable deep, honest conversations between people who don’t know each other. This requires trusting that your interlocutor cares about ideas and not social advantage, that they’re not there to suck up to someone popular or to “cancel” anyone or to fool you.
I’ve been in many spaces that have tried to achieve this by relying on social proof — who knows you and will vouch for you. But this sets the game back in the realm of social advantage. If you can accumulate favor while secretly besmirching a rival’s reputation, you gain trust by being untrustworthy. At LessOnline, who you know is important but secondary. Status comes primarily from the quality and longevity of your public blogging. After blogging for a decade, I have to admit that crazy as it sounds, I don’t personally know a single better way to create a super high-trust environment.3
The craziness is part of what makes it effective:
On the status front, the rightful caliph of rationalists is Eliezer Yudkowsky, widely perceived outside the community to be brash, arrogant, and lacking charisma. Despite the fact of his caliphdom, arguing publicly with Eliezer is one of highest-status things a rationalist can do, while merely citing him as an authority is disrespected.
People like Scott Alexander or Gwern Branwen are likewise admired despite many people not even knowing what they look like. Attributes that form the basis of many status hierarchies are heavily discounted: wealth, social grace, credentials, beauty, number of personal friends, physical shape, humor, adherence to a particular ideology. Instead, respect often flows from disreputable hobbies such as blogging.
I think that people often don’t realize that their discomfort with rationalists comes down to this. Every person cares deeply and instinctively about their standing in a community. They are distressed by status hierarchies they don’t know how to navigate.
This crazy status hierarchy, more than the hot takes and the cuddles, is why rationalism will never be mainstream. Because of that, I knew I could trust anyone at LessOnline with my hottest take or softest cuddle. Other people felt the same way. They were able to relax their constant vigilance for untrustworthy actors, trusting in the communal reputation ledger and the sociopath-repelling forcefield of cringe. They felt more comfortable being direct and rude when needed, or giving a sincere compliment. They got horny.
It’s in the Eyes
Being scrupulously truth-seeking for several years writing in public on sensitive topics is just part of the trust signal. The magic happens when people meet in person, when they put a face and body behind their writing.
The reason women wanted to sleep with Standard Deviant after his sex talk was that he carried himself throughout the weekend like someone who has a lot of sex and genuinely likes women. You can fool a drunk girl about who you are as a sex-haver long enough to get her to your hotel room, but you’re not going to fool several women with their own sex blogs for 72 hours of non-stop socializing.
It’s also why a guy whose swagger doesn’t match his status in either direction is so off-putting to girls. They sense the lack of integrity. Even if he isn’t consciously trying to fool other people, he’s fighting to fool himself. When a man is fully aligned he can’t even imagine pretending to be someone else for others, there’s no one he can be but his whole self. That’s what the girls observed about the slouching blogger at his talk, a comfort that attests to zero internal tension.
It’s hard to write about this without sounding trite, though my friend Rachel Clifton tries to. It’s more effective to point out that you know it when you see it, as she does in this example with Jeff Bezos:
I suspect that for most men, from young Jeff Bezos to the lowliest incel, the hardest thing to be fully comfortable with is their sexuality. That’s certainly true of me. How sexy do I actually think I am vs. trying to be vs. trying to project that I am? How do I disentangle my actual shifting desires from my public brand as a horny-on-main dating writer? Can I admit to myself what I’m insecure about, let alone to others? I suspect that if I ever felt 100% integrated with my sexuality I wouldn’t have a dating blog anymore. I’d just have more sex.
I didn’t have sex at LessOnline, but I got to talk about it with perceptive nonjudgmental people who were really curious and wanted to figure stuff out and help each other. And yeah, sex is great, but have you ever tried this?
Alignment Research
I don’t think rationalists are more or less lustful or kinky on average than other groups. By lucky coincidence, one of our caliphs is a married asexual romantic while the other may or may not have a harem of math pets chained to his bed. Any point on the spectrum between the two is welcome in the community. But rationalists do talk about sex a lot, mostly because they love alignment and hate conflict.
From the mainstream, this looks like we’re a mix of seedy brothel and incel forum. If you talk openly about things you’re not supposed to admit, whether it’s “ravage fantasies” or enjoying Platonic cuddles, people assume you’re either insane or lying. From the middle, the right tail looks like the left.
The same applies to individuals like Ronny and Aella. By mainstream standards, a guy with anarchist tattoos and a girl doing sex work are undesirable. Having sex with undesirable people is a sign of degeneracy, of having no standards or no shame.
Of course, Aella and Ronny both have high standards, just for different things. Aella wants men who are fully self-accepting and skillfully curious and laments how hard these are to find. Ronny likes women who are smart, brave, and very slutty — these are also in shorter supply than you’d think. Both of them value integrity and radical disclosure.
People aren’t mad that Ronny slept with Aella. They’re mad he can talk about it with his friends without shame. That other hot girls gathered to watch him get tattooed because they thought it’s hilarious. People are envious of the social context Ronny and Aella exist in, where they can both be their full sexual selves.
Abundance Agenda
The biggest shift in a man’s sex life happens when (if) he switches from a sexual scarcity mindset to sexual abundance. The former is ruled by anxiety and envy that come from seeing sex as a resource to be extracted from women in competition with other men. The latter is playful and generous, treating sex as a collaborative creation and not a commodity.
Unfortunately, you can’t force the switch by simply telling someone about the joys of abundance. It’s the end result of a slow virtuous cycle that takes many years to build on itself. A goal of my writing is to help men step onto this path, letting go of stories that keep them locked in scarcity and getting playful on the way up.
There’s a deeper shift that can happen, one that’s even rarer and less visible to society at large: the shift from trust scarcity to trust abundance. In the former, trust requires constant managing of people’s impressions of you, and every conflict puts you at risk of losing face. In the latter, managing impressions seems impossible, even nonsensical. You are the same person at ease and under pressure, and any social capital lost in conflict quickly regenerates as you stay reliably you.
To people in scarcity mindset, abundance often looks like unskilled scarcity. A sexually abundant man doesn’t flex or act possessive; people think he’s just poor or timid. A man with integrity doesn’t avoid controversy or mind his mistakes pointed out in public; people think he’s too stupid to tell an apple from a potato.
Abundance mindset isn’t a feature of the lone hermit in a cave. There must be some community where sexual opportunity and trust are, indeed, abundant. After spending the weekend at a rationalist conference, I’m starting to think that these are the same thing.
Fuck you I contain multitudes
The difference is that Aella doesn’t stick with guys because she compares them to a strict internal standard, as opposed to comparing them to the 4 other guys on your weekly dance card. Aella will get married when she finds someone who meets her criteria, but Michelle’s friend won’t find a guy who’s better than the other 54 on everything.
I’m sure there are many such environments, I’m just unfamiliar with them. I would love to hear about other examples of high-trust voluntary communities in the comments!








High-trust voluntary communities:
Famously, Amsterdam and NYC diamond dealers; my (limited) understanding of this is that it is dominated by Hasidic(?) Jews. The explanation was that co-religionists share a lot of mutual trust and understanding.
Mountaineering groups come to mind, at least the stereotypical "a group of guys climb a mountain together, without guides". With the bush league mountaineering I've done, I've definitely seen lots of mutual trust: all look out for each other and nobody is concerned about theft.
Man, that makes me jealous of people who are more geographically available for those meetups. Fucking Perm, RU is a bit too far away, and the only other person who I've ever met offline who even heard the name Yudkowski or any other rationalist stuff was my motorcycle instructor in Bali )